Cast 57
Adam Brody
Rocks
Wyatt Cenac
Gunderson
Danny Jacobs
Billy
Josh Lawson
Jake
Amber Tamblyn
Tabatha
Scott Adsit
Priest
Jon Glaser
Donkey
Matthew Daddario
Peter
Sondra James
Barb
Josh Mostel
Chuck MacArthur
David Lipman
Rabbi
Allyce Beasley
Jeanne
Andrea Leigh
Alexis Ostrander
Ted Oyama
Larry Kim
Melissa Navia
Raja
Suni Reyes
Rita
Lucy Walters
Melanie
Connor Fox
Alex
Darren Grodsky
Zeke (Captain Hook)
Anthony Lumia
Ricky
Bruce Wexler
Massimo
Michael Armstrong Barr
Doctor
Athena Alexis
Nurse (as Athenas Duché)
Alison Mitzner
Nurse (as Ali Mitzner)
Danielle Lee Greaves
Nurse
Haleigh Ciel
Hot Stoner Chick
Annabelle Attanasio
Curious Student
Adam Celentano
SAT Student
Ari Hader
SAT Student (as Arielle Hader)
Princy Thomas
SAT Student
Mikaela Brandon
Inquisitive Student
Fenton Li
Neighbor
Jaden Michael
Street Kid
Aleksandra Myrna
Cafe Patron
Merritt Chase
Shop Owner (as Merritt Matthew Chase)
Kitty Crystal
DJ (as Crystal Lonneberg)
Dan Sheynin
Church Tour Guide
Vin Scialla
Church Visitor
Alanna Dachille
Tourist
Amanda Riley
Bartender
Daniela Dakich
Liquor Store Patron
Darryle Jermaine
Coffee Shop Guest
And Palladino
Pizza Customer
Gus Renaud
Pizza Customer
Kenneth Kopolovicz
Guy Walking out of Pizzaria
Helene Macaulay
Woman in the Park
Bennie Road
Police Officer
Bianca Nejat
Bridesmaid
Demetrius Constant
Boy 1
Christian Dell'Edera
Hispanic Boy
Gabriela Duarte
Girl in Bodega
Janelle Forgette
Party Guest
Joseph Cornacchia
Party Guest
Joseph Gillen
Party Guest
Crew 23
Darren Grodsky
Director
Danny Jacobs
Writer
Danny Jacobs
Director
Darren Grodsky
Writer
Nicole Lederman
Producer
Avy Kaufman
Casting
Jason Weiss
Producer
Katie Mustard
Producer
Tim Kendall
Executive Producer
Darren Grodsky
Executive Producer
Danny Jacobs
Executive Producer
Avy Kaufman
Executive Producer
Sirad Balducci
Co-Producer
Justin R. Williams
Co-Producer
Sarah Mae Burton
Costume Design
Josh Noyes
Editor
Kathleen Johnson
Makeup Artist
Maya Sigel
Production Design
Janelle Jones
Art Direction
Amy L. Forsythe
Makeup Department Head
Christopher Baffa
Director of Photography
Fil Eisler
Original Music Composer
Philip Klein
Original Music Composer